Saturday, August 01, 2009

Drawing the Line

[This is an unauthorised report from long-time reader and sometime contributor John Steventon (the American). Since we all miss Brian, I am taking it upon myself to fill in for him on occasion. Please feel free to complain, throw stones (at a tree or something, not at me), and inform Brian if you see him at the shops. Cheers!]

In America, England, Australia.... just about anywhere, you can find history. Prehistoric peoples wandered the land and cluttered it up with burial mounds, henges, rock carvings, standing stones... you name it. All kinds of stuff that was so very important to them. Then Historic Man came along and decided everything would look nice plowed over and plundered. Then Modern Man came along and decided he could profit by building as many shopping and eating establishments as possible, and making sure there was plenty of parking to go along with it.

Brian has posted recently about a long house or something that was excavated quickly so a car park could go in on schedule. Here in Ohio archeologists had to move fast to save some very important artifacts so that a new runway could go in at the airport. Even at Stonehenge, that most famous of monuments, there is a sign at the car park saying that some 3000 year old giant carved trees had once stood on that spot, somwhere under the tarmac!

Obviously, these ancient sites meant a lot to their builders. Obviously, modern man needs places to sleep, shop, and eat pizza. So where do we draw the line? In a recent post here I was moaning about the loss of so much Native American prehistory here in Ohio. "Why oh why did they have to destroy so much?!" I cried! Then I looked at "Prehistoric Earthworks in Ohio by William C. Mills, from the 1914 Archeological Atlas of Ohio. There were thousands of earthworks, including burial mounds, ceremonial temple mounds, fortifications, village enclosures.. and then there were petroglyph sites, stone piles, and others. That's a lot of red dots on the map! See this link if you don't believe me:

So where Do we draw the line between preserving the past and making way for 'progress'? A compromise would be nice, such as living alongside the monuments from the past, but in many cases it's much too late for that. The decision should have been made years ago.

In all fairness, most people simply do not care about the past... just a bunch of roxks and dirt, some people say. So let's have a dialog here.

"The Native Americans moved into Ohio perhaps 15,000 years ago!"
"Yeah, but we is here now."
"Only because 'we' forced them from their homes!"
"Might makes right, loser!"

Never mind... this kind of conversation inevitably leads to disaster, since both sides have very different points of view. The truth is.. in most cases it is too late. Here in Ohio I've been told that everything was plowed over, so that even the monuments we see today are not truly their original selves. I've been here two weeks now, and in two different walks have seen evidence of artifacts that were ground into pieces.. broken pottery, a broken adze, a piece of clay pipe... the last two were not far from a certain burial mound I featured here, so even that was 'spoiled'.

Even in our attempts to preserve the past, I believe we are failing. Some believe that letting the land go fallow is allowing the sites to be seen in their 'natural' state. Well, just what IS their natural state? We are not sure of the purpose of many of these sites, so how do we know what they should look like? The Native Americans did not have lawn mowers, unless you count sheep, but letting grass grow on earthworks is a better method of preserving them than letting them grow fallow.

Case in point, the Jeffers Mound as seen in the photo above. The Jeffers Mound is all that is left of a vast complex that included huge earthworks, a burial mound, a ceremonial mound (the Jeffers Mound), two circular enclosures, and longhouses. Who knows what else? The land was farmed for years until it was subdivided and sold into housing lots. Mr. Jeffers thankfully did not sell the land the Jeffers Mound was on, so this is all that remains of this once great complex.

Now look at the photo above... can you even see the mound? It's like 25 feet high, but I had some people with me on the visit and they all saw a 'bunch of bushes' until I pointed out to them that it wa a mound. What bothers me though is the trees. If left in the woods, nature would eventually destroy these mounds on it's own,(see first photo above of Cole Earthworks) but this mound is supposedly being preserved, and there are 40 foot high trees growing out of it! That means there are 40 feet of roots burrowing through the mound, and when those tipping trees fall, there goes the mound.

Oh well... let's just help nature along, shall we? This site is just wasted space, innit? Let's put up a bus shelter with matching car park and put this space to use, eh?

Just remember one thing, though. These ancient peoples lived a long time ago, so we say 'their time has passed', and plow over the graves of their ancestors. Well, how would you feel if those were YOUR ancestors being plowed over? It could happen, you know. And not just in the movies. Case in point, the Pool family. They plowed over the two mounds I mentioned in my earlier blog, and lived here for some time in the 1800's. Not too long ago, right? And their gravestones were found 'somewhere south of Highbanks Metro Park, and no one is sure where their bodies are. Their stones now sit together in a little fenced off area... a 'pretend' burial plot.

And progress and history march on... :0)

Cheers, JOHN :0)


Jayne said...

Oh, John, what a can of worms you've opened up with that great post!
You've hit the nail on the head, though, no one in power/parliament/planning, etc, does care about the past.
Money, developers, the conquerors re-writing history as they see fit and good old commonsense in short supply rings a death knell to so much heritage.
Am enjoying your posts, a very able replacement for Lord Hughes :)

JahTeh said...

And yet, trees growing on mounds are the only things that have saved the Mayan temple complexes from human destruction.

I have photos of the original expedition to Copan from the Peabody and when they're compared to the complex now, it's amazing the work that's been done.

The problem in Ohio was a complete lack of respect for the 'savages' and their culture. We won't even mention the missionaries.

I saw an X-Files episode once where the man behind the computer was turned into electricity and absorbed into the circuit boards.
It could happen, when I log on to the Fylde, I could swear my screen goes hairy.

John said...

Hey, hey... that's my friend we're bashing! :0) That's all we need is for him to show up and see you two and your gentle teasing.. we all know how sensitive he can be. He may never come back.

Then again, if only we could turn a bacon butty into electricity, we may entice him back to this blog that way?

Back to archeology... I just remembered that Brian said he had some top secret work that Wyre Arch was up to this summer, but couldn't divulge to us for fear of treasure hunters sniffing it out. For all we know he's hard at work right now, watching the rest of the team dig and trowl? :0)

For the record, he has automatic blog posts until October, so yo may be stuck with me for awhile... unless you Aussies want to send me an article on Aboriginal Petroglyphs or something to post here?

Then again, maybe we should start a World Archeology blog, and invite his nibs to join US?


Back to work, JOHN :0)

John said...

Oops, now I've gone senile. Part of this was a reply to Jah Teh's comment at the last post about Brian's going senile, and part of her comments here! I just read all the comments in me mailbox without seeing the posts they were attributed to, and thought Jayne was bashing Brian as well.

I need my head examined... or at least to wake up enough before commenting!

Cheers, Jayne, for the nice comments, and sorry Jah Teh for coming down so hard. I just don't want Brian peeping in here(as opposed to in his neighbors widows), and finding us past the 'grief' stage, and onto the 'good grief' stage, and not missing him anymore. :0)

Good grief, when the comments get longer than the post, it's time to shut up and get lunch!

Just ignore me everyone... I'll snap out of it, once I've settled. JOHN :0)

Jayne said...

John, I'd happily send you info on Aboriginal Archaeology...except there isn't any.
Well, there is some but very little funding + archaeologists and palaeontologists leaving the country in droves for UK/USA there's no bugger left to dig!
Many of us would only bash Brian with a piece of wet spaghetti but don't tell him that ;)

JahTeh said...

John, beating Fleetwood around the head with anything is the closest he gets to being loved.

'Sensitive' it's not a word we usually associate with the big idle ditchdigger and we do miss him. *gags*

Like Jayne says not much on the archaeology front but plenty on our dinosaur finds in Queensland.

Brian Hughes said...

Okay chaps...just dropping by to make sure everything's still ticking over. (John seems to have got the hang of keeping this website going, by the look of it.) I'm not back online yet (stop cheering)...just testing one of those dongle things out on my spare computer at the moment. I'm also in the middle of decorating, so don't expect me back too soon. Right...back to John and I'm off for a beef and mustard butty.Be seein' you.

John said...

Whoa! I feel like a ghost just walked through me! Was that an actual visitation from Lord Hughes, hisself?

I'm not sure, he sounds more... mature... or something.

And DECORATING? I can't imagine Brian decorating anything... not even a cake(since he'd be eating the cake while Michelle's getting the icing ready)

Jah Teh(or can I call you Witchy, as well), personally, I'd love to hear about some dinosaurs. Anything particularly news-worthy going on in your backyard?(and I'm not talking about the Mid-summer daisy chain during the folk festival, either) :0)

Alright, I'm off before I get into trouble. I'm just giddy from that visitation, and desperate for some hot coffee to take the chills off my spine.

New post from Brian coming up, and I'll try to work something out for the weekend.

JOHN :0)

JahTeh said...

John, he's definitely getting a bit posh, beef and mustard butty instead of his usual manky bacon and chip ones. Next thing you know he'll be combing his hair and using a hanky instead of his sleeve.

Big dino news is finding small dino burrows where they sheltered during the southern cold.
So now I'll have to find them instead of doing the vacuuming.

John said...

Jah Teh,
Now, see? I've never heard of dino burrows, so that sounds like fun!

As for his Nibs, I'm not sure a comb would work with that hair. :0)

AS for me, I'm not sure I should continue here... I thought I was helping out, but if you notice, none of Brian's comments were directed to me, so mebbe I overstepped me boundaries?

Either that or Big B has trouble saying thanks?

We'll see if I can mend my feelings by the weekend. Meanwhile, I'm sure HE has a perfectly wonderful post due later today.

Sniff, sob... JOHN :0/